Skip to main content

Prospect Bucket Slotting Checklist

Run this once per prospect, before the send checklist. It assigns exactly one bucket from the Prospecting Bucket Taxonomy. About ten minutes.

This checklist contains no judgement calls. Every threshold is a number. If two people run it on the same prospect they must reach the same bucket. If you find yourself deciding rather than counting, stop and flag the step — the checklist is wrong, not you.

Do not contact the prospect while running this. No test texts to their business number, no calls, no form submissions. Everything here is observable from public pages.

What you need open​

  1. The prospect card in Marketing > Prospecting (sub-account, not the agency nav)
  2. The audit report PDF or shareable link
  3. A browser, ideally a private window so your own Google account does not colour the results

Fill the record at the bottom as you go.


Step 1 — Triage, from the record alone​

Three checks, seconds each, before anything is opened. This is layer 1 of the Prospect Qualification Standard. It reads only what the record already carries, so it is not a second pass over the Google Business Profile. Any one failing parks the prospect.

  • 1a. AI conversion score above 60%?
    • No → stop. Park the prospect. Do not open the report.
    • No score on the record → skip this check and note it skipped. Externally sourced contacts have no prospect card. Skipped is not failed, and it is not a reason to guess.
    • Yes → continue.
  • 1b. Rating and review count — read both off the record and write them down. They decide the bucket at step 9 and they are the first half of Results-First gate 3. You are not judging them yet; you are carrying them forward so step 4 and step 10d are not re-reading the profile.
  • 1c. Trade — is it one where a single new customer is plausibly worth $3,000 or more? Roofing, HVAC replacement, construction and remodeling, masonry, excavation and flooring clear that comfortably. Mowing and maintenance, cleaning, handyman work and most single-visit repair do not.
    • No → the prospect is still workable on standard terms, but Results-First is off the table. Note it and continue.

Do not use the audit report's Overall Score for 1a. It is a different number and it means close to the opposite thing.

⚠️ 1c is a proxy and it is wrong sometimes — a design-build landscaper clears $3,000 easily. A proxy decides what to source, never what to disqualify. The real question is asked on the demo, which is where gate 5 now lives.


Step 2 — Confirm it is the right business​

The single most expensive error in this process. If the audit resolved to a different business, every reputation and location finding in it is worthless.

  • 2a. Google the business name plus the town.
  • 2b. Open the Google Business Profile that appears in the panel on the right.
  • 2c. Compare three things against the contact record: business name, street address, phone number.
  • 2d. Do all three match?
    • No → stop. Record wrong-business, flag the report for refresh, move on.
    • Yes → continue.
  • 2e. Check for any of these on the profile or the site. Any one of them stops the prospect:
    • Marked permanently closed, or the website does not load
    • They are a marketing agency, web designer, or CRM consultant
    • They are already an SC client or an open lead
    • No Google Business Profile exists at all

Step 3 — Read the report for signals​

You are collecting inputs, not findings. Nothing you write down in this step goes in an email.

  • 3a. Open the report. On the first page, note the section scores in the record below.
  • 3b. Find the section titled Business Critical Information. Note whether it flags:
    • Text Enabled Business Number — SMS-capable, yes or no
    • Chat Widget on Website — present, yes or no
  • 3c. Find Technology Stack. Note whether a scheduling or booking tool was detected.
  • 3d. Ignore the Website Performance and SEO scores entirely. They are the documented false-positive producers and nothing in this checklist depends on them.

Step 4 — Count the reviews by hand​

Never take these numbers from the report. Count them on the live profile.

  • 4a. On the Google Business Profile from step 2, read the star rating. Write it down.
  • 4b. Read the number of Google reviews. Write it down. This is the count next to the stars, not the count on Facebook, Yelp, or anywhere else.
  • 4c. Click through to the reviews and sort by Newest.
  • 4d. Look at the newest 10 reviews (or all of them, if there are fewer than 10). For each one, look underneath it for a block labelled Response from the owner.
  • 4e. Count how many of those 10 have one. Record it as n of 10.
  • 4f. Note the date of the most recent review that has no owner response.

Step 5 — Count the competitors​

This produces the number that makes a B1 email work. Skip it and the email has nothing in it.

  • 5a. Open Google Maps.
  • 5b. Search the prospect's trade plus their town, phrased the way a customer would: septic service Southbury CT, HVAC repair Waterbury CT.
  • 5c. From the results list, take the top three businesses that are genuine competitors — same trade, same area. Skip directories, national chains with no local presence, and the prospect themselves.
  • 5d. For each, write down the review count.
  • 5e. Note where the prospect appears in that list, if at all. This is context for you, not for the email.

Step 6 — Open the website​

Look at the real site, not the report's opinion of it.

  • 6a. Open the prospect's website. Wait ten seconds before judging anything — chat widgets and embeds load late.
  • 6b. Contact form: is there any form anywhere on the site with fields you could type into and submit? Check the homepage, the contact page, and the footer. A phone number, an email address, or a button that only scrolls down the page is not a form.
  • 6c. Chat widget: is there a chat bubble, usually bottom right?
  • 6d. Booking: is there anything that lets a customer pick a time or request an appointment online? A "Contact Us" link is not booking.
  • 6e. While you are here, note anything showing they already want reviews: written testimonials, a "leave us a review" button, review badges. This is the strongest tell for B1 and it belongs in the record.

Step 7 — Check the phone path​

  • 7a. From step 3b, is the listed number SMS-capable?
  • 7b. On the Google Business Profile, read the opening hours.
  • 7c. Does the website list a separate after-hours or emergency number?
  • 7d. Mark the after-hours path as present only if there is a distinct number or a stated after-hours service. Voicemail is not a path.

Step 8 — Identify the decision-maker​

  • 8a. Read the site's About page in full. Owners change, and About pages are where that is said.
  • 8b. Cross-check against the Google Business Profile and the Facebook page.
  • 8c. Does the name on the contact record match a person who currently runs the business?
    • No → correct it before any send. If you cannot establish who runs it, the prospect is not sendable yet. Record what you found and stop.
    • Yes → continue.
  • 8d. Confirm First name holds a person's name, not the business name. The prospecting agent writes the business name into that field by default.

A business named after a person tells you nothing about who owns it now. Founder names outlive founders.


Step 9 — Walk the tree​

Top to bottom. Stop at the first line that is true.

  • 9a. Rating from 4a is 4.0 or higher, and review count from 4b is under 15? → B1 Review Engine. Stop.
  • 9b. Review count from 4b is 15 or more, and step 4e found fewer than 5 of 10 with an owner response? → B2 Review Response. Stop.
  • 9c. Number is not SMS-capable (7a) or there is no after-hours path (7d), and the trade is emergency-shaped? → B3 Missed Calls. Stop.
  • 9d. No contact form (6b) and no chat widget (6c)? → B4 No Contact Path. Stop.
  • 9e. No booking (6d) and the trade is appointment-shaped? → B5 No Online Booking. Stop.
  • 9f. Nothing matched → park the prospect. Do not invent a finding to fill the gap.

Trade shape is the table in the taxonomy. Emergency beats appointment when a trade is both.


Step 10 — Record it​

  • 10a. Write audit_finding_used as a short noun phrase carrying the real number, so it reads inside a sentence. Not a sentence, not a percentage.

  • 10b. Write the buckets into the slotting record below. Do not set the field on the contact — Prospect Bucket Options is written by the caller at call prep, with the report open, and a desk value would be overwritten. What you produce here is the recommendation she checks against.

    Record every outcome the tree ticked, not just the first. Step 9 is a rank order, not a stop-at-first walk:

    OutcomeValue
    Step 9areview-engine
    Step 9breview-response
    Step 9cmissed-calls
    Step 9dno-contact-path
    Step 9eno-booking
    Step 9f, nothing tickedparked-no-match
    Stopped at step 2disqualified

    The lead is the highest ticked. parked-no-match and disqualified are exclusive — recorded alone or not at all.

    ⚠️ The values lost their B1- to B5- prefixes on 2026-10-30. Writing B1-review-engine will not match anything.

    Never leave the record blank. Blank means nobody slotted this prospect. Parked and disqualified are real outcomes and both have a value; recording them is how the reply rates stay honest.

  • 10c. Confirm the contact's City is populated. The emails merge it and the agent fills it, so this is a check rather than a task.

  • 10d. Results-first eligibility. You already have every signal on screen; this costs about fifteen seconds. Note eligible or not in the slotting record, with the first gate that failed.

    All seven must hold. Full terms and rationale in the SC Results-First Offer — do not quote the offer from memory, and do not mention it to a prospect while that document is draft.

    GateThresholdRead it from
    GBP exists and resolvesVerified, right businessStep 2
    Working websiteLoads, theirs, not a Facebook pageSteps 2e, 6
    Existing demand≥10 reviews lifetime, and ≥1 in the last 90 daysStep 4
    Decision-makerNamed, currently runs itStep 8
    ICP screenNot answerable here. Revenue, headcount and deal value are not on a public page — gate 5 is asked on the demo. Step 1c's trade proxy is what you have at this pointQualification Standard §3
    BucketB1, B2 or B3 onlyStep 10b
    SMS pathSMS-capable, or will A2P registerStep 7

    The demand gate is the one that usually fails, and that is the point. A business with no recent customers produces no leads to capture, so SC could build everything correctly and still have nothing to bill. Not eligible is a normal outcome — most prospects get standard terms.

  • 10e. Hand off to the send checklist.

Slotting record​

Paste this into the verification note and fill it in.

Prospect:
Card conversion score: % (gate: >60)
Right business confirmed: Y / N
Decision-maker: (source: )
Trade: Shape: emergency / appointment

GBP rating: Review count:
Owner responses: of 10 Oldest unanswered:
Competitor counts: / /

Contact form: Y / N Chat: Y / N Booking: Y / N
SMS-capable: Y / N After-hours path: Y / N
Already asking for reviews:

BUCKETS TICKED: (every line of step 9 that was true)
LEAD BUCKET: (the highest one)
audit_finding_used:
Results-first eligible: Y / N First gate failed:

Worked example: Talarico Septic and Excavating​

Run against the audit report dated 2026-09-10 and the site capture taken the same day.

StepObservation
1Card conversion score above 60. Gate passed
2Talarico Septic & Excavating LLC, 203 Old Waterbury Rd, Southbury CT 06488, +1 203-264-8896. Name, address and phone all match. Not an agency, not a client, profile is live
3Report sections: Business Critical 0%, Techno Stack 0%, GBP 100%, Website Performance 94%, Reputation 30%, Local SEO 40%. Flags: number not SMS-capable, no chat widget. No scheduling tool detected
45.0 stars. 1 Google review. Zero owner responses. Facebook separately shows 5/5 from 4 votes, which does not count
5Septic competitors in Southbury are established firms with many multiples of one review. Prospect does not appear in the top three
6No contact form anywhere on the site. The "Contact Us Today" button scrolls to a block listing a phone number and an email address. No chat widget. No booking. Five written testimonials on the homepage, and a "Give Us a Review" button already sitting next to them
7Not SMS-capable. Hours Mon-Fri 7am-4pm. A separate 24-hour emergency number is published, so an after-hours path exists
8The contact record is wrong. The About page states the company was founded as Frank Talarico & Son in 1949, that Frank retired, and that he sold the business to Matt Cisero and Lane Bond in late 2024. The prospect folder is named "frank talarico". Emailing Frank would open with a factual error about the business
9Three lines tick. 9a: rating 5.0, 1 review → review-engine. 9c: not SMS-capable, and septic is emergency-shaped → missed-calls (the trigger is not SMS-capable or no after-hours path, so his published 24-hour number does not save him). 9d: no form, no chat → no-contact-path. 9e: no booking, but septic is emergency-shaped, so no tick. Lead: review-engine

Ticked: review-engine, missed-calls, no-contact-path. Lead: review-engine. audit_finding_used: one Google review, against five written testimonials on your own homepage

Three things this example is here to teach:

The lead is review-engine even though two other lines tick, and those two are not wasted. Talarico has no form, no chat and a phone that cannot receive texts. Every one is a real problem and none is what you open with — the review gap is the one he can verify in ten seconds while you are still on the phone. But if he shrugs at it, the caller has two more findings ready instead of improvising. Under the old single-select both were thrown away.

The one line that does not tick is killed by the trade, not by the evidence. He has no booking tool, but septic is emergency-shaped and no-booking is gated on appointment-shaped work. Trade shape is doing real work in this tree, not decoration — and it is the step people skip.

Step 8 is not paperwork. Under the old flow this prospect would have received an email addressed to a man who sold the company two years ago. Nothing else in the email would have survived that.

The testimonials are the whole pitch. He is not a business that neglects reviews. He is a business that already asks for them, with a button on his own site, and gets one. That is a working method problem, not an awareness problem, and it is a much easier conversation.

Document History​

VersionDateChanges
1.72026-11-10Gate 5 is asked on the demo, not the cold call, following the call scripts v1.19
1.62026-11-02Published to the team wiki. Ticking the buckets is a daily caller activity, and the caller has wiki access and no repository access — so the checklist behind the activity was unreachable by the only person who runs it
1.52026-10-30Step 10b stops writing the contact field. The live field became a multi-select owned by the caller, who sets it at call prep with the report open; a desk-written value would be overwritten, so this step now produces the recommendation she checks rather than the record itself. Step 10b records every outcome the tree ticked instead of only the first, because the tree is now a rank order. Value names updated — the B1- to B5- prefixes are gone from live and writing them matches nothing. The Talarico example is re-cut and gets sharper: it now shows two ticks with review-engine leading, which teaches both what leads and what the single-select was discarding, and it shows trade shape killing two of the four candidate lines
1.42026-10-09Step 1 becomes a three-check triage: the conversion score as before, plus rating and review count, plus the trade. All three read off the record, so nothing is opened twice. The score check now tolerates its own absence — externally sourced contacts have no prospect card, which made this checklist structurally inapplicable to the larger supply route; skipped is recorded as skipped rather than guessed. Step 10d's ICP row stops claiming to answer gate 5: revenue, headcount and per-customer value are not observable from a public page, so the gate was being waved through on every prospect. It moves to the call, with the trade as its sourcing proxy. Placement rules are in the new Prospect Qualification Standard
1.32026-09-23Step 10d assesses results-first offer eligibility, and 10e is the old 10d handoff. The seven gates are read off signals steps 2, 4, 6, 7 and 8 already collected, so this is a fifteen-second judgement rather than a second pass — a separate checklist re-reading the same Google Business Profile is how two documents start disagreeing. Six gates are existing canon gathered in one place; the demand gate (≥10 reviews lifetime, ≥1 in 90 days) is new, and is the one that decides whether the offer is survivable, because a business with no recent customers produces no leads however well the build goes
1.22026-09-16Step 10c no longer asks for trade. The templates no longer merge it, and the trade still drives the B3/B5 shape judgement in step 9 as knowledge rather than as a stored field
1.12026-09-10Step 10b now writes the live prospect_bucket field (jCdKeYfwzNaTPWn6j5o5) with the outcome-to-value map, including the two no-send outcomes
1.02026-09-10Initial checklist, with the Talarico worked example