Skip to main content

Prospecting Review Response Play

Deprecated 2026-11-09. Do not run this play. Every call now closes on the Results-First offer, which does not reply to reviews. For a prospect whose finding is its reviews, use Opener B and the "Which finding leads" table in Prospecting Cold Call Scripts.

The prospecting cadence built around a single problem: Google reviews going unanswered. One finding, one fix, one guarantee.

This play is Bucket 2. It applies to a prospect with 15 or more Google reviews where fewer than 5 of the newest 10 carry an owner reply. A prospect with too few reviews to respond to is not disqualified any more; they belong in Bucket 1. Which bucket a prospect is in is decided by the Slotting Checklist before any email is drafted.

This play does not replace the outreach cadence SOP; it is a specialization of it. The touch structure, stop rules, and tag state model are unchanged. What changes is that every touch carries the same finding and the same offer.

Why this finding​

The generic audit hand-off points at "the strongest finding", which varies per prospect and makes every asset a fresh judgement call. Collapsing onto one finding is worth more than the flexibility it costs, for four reasons that are specific to reviews:

ReasonEvidence
It is the audit's most reliable sectionOnline Reputation is rated "High for Google reviews", pulled from Google's API. Website Performance and SEO are the documented false-positive producers. See Audit Accuracy SOP
The prospect can check it in twenty secondsThe pre-call gate requires a finding "verifiable by the prospect in about twenty seconds on their own phone". Reviews clear this better than anything else in the report
SC can fix it today, in daysAI Review Response SOP is active. It needs a connected Google Business Profile and nothing else, which makes it a days-not-weeks subset of the 13-20 day onboarding
It costs almost nothing to deliverRoughly one cent per review response. That is what makes the guarantee below affordable rather than reckless

There is also a targeting alignment worth naming. The Prospect AI agent currently filters on GBP ratings Below 3.0, so every prospect arriving in the pipeline already has a reputation problem. The offer and the audience were chosen independently and happen to match.

The rule that keeps this honest​

Never quote the widget's response-rate number. The Audit Accuracy SOP flags it directly: recent responses may not be reflected yet. An owner who replied to reviews last week, told by a stranger that they never reply, has been handed a reason to distrust everything else in the report. It is instantly checkable and it fails in the worst direction.

A second, harder failure: if the audit resolved the wrong business, the entire reputation section is void. This has happened, and it is documented in the Marketing Audit Production PRD.

So, before any prospect enters this play:

  1. Open the prospect's live Google Business Profile.
  2. Confirm it is genuinely their business: name, address, and phone match the contact record.
  3. Count, by hand, how many of the most recent reviews carry an owner response.
  4. Note the date of the most recent unanswered review.
  5. Record the real number in Audit Finding Used, phrased as a short noun phrase.

If the count does not support the claim, the prospect does not enter this play. Pick another finding or another prospect. This is a gate, not a courtesy.

The offer​

The Review Response Guarantee. Every Google review gets a published response within 48 hours, or that month is free.

Full terms, including what counts as a miss and how a refund is issued, are in SC Review Response Guarantee. Read them before promising anything on a call.

The guarantee does the work a case study would normally do. SC has no published client outcome on reviews, so rather than assert a result we cannot evidence, the offer removes the prospect's risk entirely. They do not need to believe a claim; they need only notice that they cannot lose.

Two things the guarantee is not:

  • It is not a promise about rating, review volume, or ranking. SC does not guarantee outcomes it does not control.
  • It is not a discount. Pricing is unchanged. AUDIT50 still applies where eligible, and it is mentioned after the value, never before it.

The cadence​

Structure, stop rules, and tags follow the cadence SOP. What this play specifies is the content of each touch.

TouchDayChannelContent
10EmailTemplate 9. One link, the report. The finding, stated as a hand-verified count. Ask: reply
23EmailTemplate 10. One link, the demo video. Ask: reply. No calendar link
37Call, optionalOpener B lineage, referencing the report and the video
410EmailTemplate 5, carrying the guarantee and AUDIT50
560 to 90EmailRe-activation, audit refreshed first

Every touch leads with the same finding. The consistency rule already in the templates file applies with more force here: Audit Finding Used is merged into the touch-1 email, the touch-2 email, and the call task. Two different findings across two touches reads as a mail merge, which is the impression the whole approach exists to avoid.

Qualification​

The ICP screen applies unchanged: $100,000 to $2,000,000 revenue, 2 to 50 headcount, one new customer worth $3,000 or more, an owner or named decision maker.

Additional disqualifiers specific to this play:

  • No connected Google Business Profile is possible. If the prospect does not control the Google account that owns their profile, the fix cannot be delivered and the guarantee cannot be honored. This has blocked real onboarding before.
  • Fewer than 15 reviews. There is not enough to respond to for the offer to mean anything. This is not a rejection: the prospect belongs in Bucket 1, where the finding is too few reviews rather than unanswered ones, and the offer is an ungated review request running after every job.
  • The reviews are not theirs. Wrong-business match. Stop and correct the record.

What happens when they reply​

A reply on any channel gets a same-day response on that channel, per the cadence SOP, and the prospect moves to RESPONDED with remaining touches stopped.

The conversation from there is short, because the offer is narrow:

  1. Confirm the review count together, on their screen. This is the moment the audit becomes real to them.
  2. Confirm they control the Google account that owns the profile.
  3. Explain what happens to reviews under three stars: held for a human, never auto-published. Owners ask this, and the answer is a trust builder rather than a caveat.
  4. Set the expectation on speed: configured within the first week once the profile is connected.

If they ask about getting more reviews rather than responding to existing ones, that is Bucket 1 and it is now a service SC sells. The answer is: every customer gets asked, after the job, by text or email, and every one of them goes to Google. SC does not screen who gets asked and does not route anybody away from the public profile. The review solicitation policy is the canon; do not describe any version of it that filters.

Document History​

VersionDateChanges
1.22026-11-09Deprecated in place: superseded by the Results-First offer, whose terms its guarantee, free month and AUDIT50 contradict
1.12026-09-10Repositioned as Bucket 2 of the Prospecting Bucket Taxonomy. The low-count disqualifier now routes to Bucket 1 instead of dead-ending at 3 reviews, and its floor is raised to 15. The 'do not improvise' block on review generation is retired: the review solicitation policy answers it
1.02026-09-09Initial play. Single-finding cadence built on unanswered Google reviews, the hand-verification gate, and the Review Response Guarantee